QPAREB Predicts More Balanced Quebec Market in 2023

The Quebec Professional Association of Real Estate Brokers (QPAREB) has released its comprehensive analysis of the province’s real estate landscape for 2022, alongside a detailed forecast for the upcoming year, 2023. This insightful report provides critical perspectives on market dynamics, price trends, sales volumes, and the overarching factors shaping the Quebec housing sector.

The past year presented a complex picture for Quebec’s real estate. While 2022 saw median prices reach unprecedented highs across all property categories, particularly single-family homes which experienced a substantial 13 percent increase compared to 2021, the market also grappled with significant shifts. This upward price trajectory, however, was accompanied by a notable downturn in sales activity. The province witnessed a historic 20 percent decline in sales over the year, a sharp contrast to the record-breaking levels observed during much of the pandemic period.

Despite this significant dip in transactions, the overall activity in 2022 remained robust, far exceeding the average of the past decade. The QPAREB, leveraging data from its Centris provincial database of real estate brokers, estimated approximately 88,000 sales across Quebec. This suggests that while the pace of the market slowed considerably, the underlying demand and transactional volume remained strong relative to historical norms.

Unpacking the 2022 Market Dynamics: The Impact of Interest Rates

A primary driver of the market’s turbulence in 2022 was the unexpected and rapid escalation of interest rates. Charles Brant, Director of QPAREB’s Market Analysis Department, highlighted the profound impact of these monetary policy adjustments. “The magnitude of interest rate increases defied all predictions,” Brant explained. “The key interest rate rose by four percentage points in less than 10 months, primarily due to runaway inflation and the outbreak of the Ukraine conflict. The resulting resale market turbulence over the first six months of the year was fuelled by the number of variable rate mortgages.”

This aggressive tightening by the Bank of Canada, a direct response to persistent inflationary pressures and global geopolitical uncertainties, fundamentally altered the affordability landscape for prospective homebuyers. The swift rise in borrowing costs meant that many buyers found their purchasing power diminished, and the financial calculations that underpinned their homebuying decisions were suddenly recalibrated. This created a period of uncertainty, particularly for those with variable-rate mortgages who faced immediate increases in their monthly payments, prompting some to reconsider their market positions.

Price Corrections Emerge as Interest Rates Soar

The sharp and sustained rise in interest rates inevitably led to a much-needed price correction in the second half of 2022. After experiencing substantial gains during the initial months of the year, property values began to moderate. QPAREB attributes this correction primarily to the growing difficulty buyers faced in qualifying for mortgages. As lending standards tightened and stress tests became more stringent due to higher rates, the pool of eligible buyers shrank considerably, leading to an easing of the previously overheated market conditions.

Certain regions, particularly those prone to intense overbidding phenomena during the pandemic boom, experienced these price corrections more acutely and rapidly. Metropolitan areas like Gatineau and Montreal, which had seen aggressive bidding wars and substantial price appreciation, were among the first to witness a cooling trend. Beyond these major urban centers, several other markets demonstrated even greater reactivity to the shifting economic landscape. Resort markets, such as Mont-Tremblant, Rawdon, and Saint-Adèle, which often attract speculative or secondary home buyers, saw significant adjustments. Similarly, markets adjacent to the bustling Montreal region, including Saint-Hyacinthe and Granby, also felt the immediate effects of increased borrowing costs and reduced buyer enthusiasm, leading to more pronounced price adjustments.

Quebec Market Conditions Still Favor Sellers, Despite Shifts

Despite the considerable decline in sales volume and the subsequent price corrections experienced in the latter half of 2022, QPAREB’s analysis reveals that market conditions throughout Quebec largely continued to favor sellers. This might seem counterintuitive given the slowdown, but it underscores a critical underlying imbalance within the housing market: a persistent shortage of available properties.

While active listings did see an increase in many markets across the province, they nonetheless remained historically low. The inventory of available properties was simply not sufficient to meet the still-present, albeit reduced, buyer demand. This scarcity meant that the number of months required to sell the existing inventory of properties remained significantly below the threshold typically associated with a balanced market. In a truly balanced market, supply and demand are in equilibrium, offering neither buyers nor sellers a distinct advantage. However, in Quebec, the limited inventory meant that properties, despite a slower pace of sales, continued to move relatively quickly. Consequently, sellers maintained a notable degree of bargaining power, often able to achieve prices close to or above their asking, even as the market adjusted.

Looking Ahead: QPAREB’s 2023 Quebec Real Estate Forecast

Peering into 2023, QPAREB anticipates that the Quebec real estate market will continue to be influenced by the trajectory of interest rates. However, the outlook suggests a gradual stabilization and even a modest increase in sales activity as the year progresses. This expected rebound is largely predicated on the return of buyers who were sidelined or unable to enter the market during the more turbulent and high-interest rate environment of 2022. As inflation potentially moderates and interest rate hikes perhaps slow or pause, a segment of deferred demand is expected to re-engage with the market.

Specific regional forecasts offer a nuanced perspective. In Quebec City, QPAREB expects sales figures to normalize, returning to a rate more closely aligned with its historical average. This suggests a period of predictability and stability for the capital region. Meanwhile, the Montreal market is projected to stabilize around levels comparable to those observed in 2016. This benchmark indicates a healthier, less frantic market pace than the pandemic peak, potentially offering more sustainable growth and fewer drastic fluctuations.

Charles Brant provided a broader provincial perspective on the forthcoming year. “Overall, the residential real estate market in the province of Quebec should continue to slow in 2023, although at a rate half that of 2022, i.e., with a nine percent drop in sales,” Brant stated. This anticipated deceleration at a milder pace than the previous year suggests that the most acute period of adjustment may be behind us. While sales are still expected to decline, the reduced magnitude of this drop points towards a market finding its footing and moving towards greater equilibrium.

Furthermore, Brant elaborated on the implications for market conditions and prices. “At this rate, market conditions should remain either favourable to sellers or close to a balanced market, depending on the specific location. Consequently, median prices for single-family homes in Quebec should fall by only five percent compared to 2022.” This forecast of a relatively modest 5 percent price reduction for single-family homes across the province is significant. It implies that while affordability remains a concern, the underlying strength of demand and limited supply will likely prevent a more drastic market correction, supporting property values against a steeper decline.

Persistent Housing Deficit: Demand Continues to Outweigh Supply

A critical underlying factor shaping both the current state and future trajectory of the Quebec real estate market is the enduring housing deficit. The QPAREB firmly notes that the current housing supply is insufficient to adequately cope with ongoing demographic changes, including population growth and evolving household structures. This structural imbalance is exacerbated by a slowdown in housing starts, which provides very limited opportunities to rectify the existing shortfall. The construction sector has faced its own challenges, from labor shortages to increased material costs and regulatory hurdles, all contributing to a sluggish pace of new home development.

This continued supply shortage is not merely an economic statistic; it has tangible impacts on affordability and market dynamics. QPAREB expects that this persistent imbalance between demand and supply will be a key factor in stabilizing the market throughout 2023. By keeping inventory levels tight, the supply shortage is anticipated to prevent a significant swing in market conditions in favor of buyers, even as sales volumes adjust and prices moderate. Essentially, while the frenetic pace of recent years may dissipate, the scarcity of homes means that sellers will likely retain a significant portion of their leverage. This ensures that Quebec’s real estate market, despite experiencing a necessary cooling period, is unlikely to transform into a deeply entrenched buyer’s market in the foreseeable future, maintaining a delicate balance that leans towards sellers or a neutral position.