Power of Sale Properties Surge in Toronto: Navigating the Complexities of a Shifting Market

The Toronto real estate market, long characterized by its rapid growth and competitive bidding wars, is currently witnessing a significant shift. Amidst fluctuating economic conditions and a landscape of rising interest rates, opportunities for Power of Sale (POS) properties are experiencing an unprecedented surge. This escalating trend is placing immense pressure on homeowners, private lenders, and real estate professionals alike. Experts are noting a dramatic increase in defaults, with one seasoned realtor revealing he’s handled six such cases in just three months, and private lenders grappling with a substantial backlog of defaulted files.

This article delves into the reasons behind the proliferation of Power of Sale properties in the Greater Toronto Area, outlines the unique characteristics of these transactions, and provides crucial insights for all parties involved – from homeowners facing financial distress to opportunistic buyers and realtors navigating this challenging yet potentially lucrative segment of the market.

The Rising Tide of Power of Sale Listings

Historically, Power of Sale situations were a relative rarity, especially during the periods of low interest rates and booming demand seen throughout the pandemic. However, the economic climate has shifted dramatically. Steven Sarasin, a prominent realtor with Re/Max Hallmark York Group Realty in Aurora, confirms this trend, stating, “I’m getting more and more calls.” He attributes this directly to the sustained high interest rates, which are making it increasingly difficult for a growing number of homeowners to meet their mortgage payment obligations.

The anecdotal evidence is supported by hard data. A private lender recently informed Sarasin of an impending influx, remarking, “There’s another $5 million worth (of POS) coming in a couple of months.” This points to a systemic issue rather than isolated incidents, suggesting a larger wave of defaults is yet to hit the market.

Data Illustrates a Clear Upward Trajectory

Visual data further underscores this dramatic increase. Toronto realtor Daniel Foch shared a compelling graph on X (formerly Twitter), tracking the number of monthly Toronto Regional Real Estate Board (TRREB) listings that specifically mention “power of sale” or “mortgage” in the seller’s name. This metric, which registered zero at the start of 2020, soared to approximately 85 listings by July 2023, indicating a rapid acceleration in POS activity.

pic.twitter.com/jwqazVzWIq

— Daniel Foch (@daniel_foch) October 9, 2023

Adding another layer to this analysis, realtor Jon Flynn also posted a graph on X, detailing the growth of active bank and Power of Sale listings on TRREB. His findings reveal a consistent month-over-month increase of approximately 10 percent since July, reaching almost 150 active listings during the week of October 8th. Flynn’s research extended beyond the core Toronto board, demonstrating a similar pattern in the boards surrounding the GTA. Here, active bank and POS listings escalated from fewer than 10 during the week of January 16, 2023, to nearly 60 by the week of October 8th. This indicates a broader regional impact of the current economic pressures.

Active bank and power of sales on the Toronto Real Estate Board are increasing by around 10% a month since July. pic.twitter.com/4FLuj28VRQ — Jon Flynn (@JonFlynnREstats) October 9, 2023

Understanding Power of Sale: Distinguishing it from Foreclosure

It’s crucial to understand what a Power of Sale entails and how it differs from a foreclosure. In Canada, particularly in Ontario, a Power of Sale is a common legal remedy for lenders when a homeowner defaults on their mortgage payments. Unlike a judicial foreclosure, which involves the courts extensively and transfers property ownership directly to the lender, a Power of Sale allows the lender to sell the property directly to recover the outstanding debt without necessarily taking title to the property themselves. This process is generally quicker and less expensive for the lender than a full foreclosure.

However, this streamlined process comes with significant implications for buyers. Properties sold under Power of Sale are typically purchased “as-is, where-is.” This means the lender, acting as the seller, makes no representations or guarantees regarding crucial aspects such as zoning and legal use, the physical condition of the property, property boundaries, or even the inclusion of fixtures. Buyers are expected to conduct their own exhaustive due diligence, as the burden of discovering any potential issues falls entirely on them.

The Dominance of Private Lenders in POS Cases

A significant portion of the current Power of Sale cases, according to Steven Sarasin, involves properties with first or second mortgages from private lenders. The rise of private and alternative lending channels has been a notable feature of the Canadian housing market in recent years. Many homeowners who are unable to secure conventional loans from traditional banks, often due to stricter lending criteria or perceived higher risk, turn to these alternative sources despite their typically higher interest rates.

This reliance on private financing, while offering a lifeline to some, also carries increased risk. When economic conditions worsen and interest rates climb, these higher-interest private loans become unsustainable for many. Sarasin notes a stark consequence: a private lender he collaborates with has significantly scaled back its mortgage offerings due to the overwhelming increase in defaults. This creates a challenging cycle: as more defaults occur, lenders become more cautious, potentially pushing even more borrowers towards precarious financial positions.

The legal system is also feeling the strain. Lawyers are “busy dealing with defaults,” Sarasin states, explaining that the process leading to legal action in a Power of Sale is lengthy, causing significant backlogs in law firms. This delay can further complicate the situation for both lenders seeking to recoup their investments and homeowners hoping to find a resolution.

Creativity and Challenges in Selling POS Properties

Selling Power of Sale properties often demands a unique approach, particularly for realtors working on behalf of private lenders. Steven Sarasin, who frequently handles such sales, highlights that “creativity is sometimes required to sell POS properties.” Lenders, motivated to recoup their investments, may find themselves needing to go beyond simply listing the property.

In some recent sales, private lenders had to inject substantial capital – often six-figure sums – into the properties to bring them to a sellable condition. This investment might involve essential repairs, significant clean-up, or necessary upgrades to make the home appealing to potential buyers. Furthermore, in an effort to incentivize sales and move properties quickly, Sarasin recounts instances where “We actually had to then go ahead and offer any interested buyers a vendor take-back at a pretty good rate to get them to buy the property.” A vendor take-back mortgage (VTB) means the seller (in this case, the lender) provides a portion of the financing to the buyer, which can be a powerful tool to close a deal, especially in a challenging market.

Navigating Realtor Rights and Responsibilities in POS Cases

The complexities of Power of Sale situations extend deeply into the realm of realtors’ rights and responsibilities, often creating ethical dilemmas and financial risks for agents. Sarasin shared a particularly poignant case in Scarborough involving a former teacher of his who was facing severe financial hardship. The homeowner hired Sarasin to sell the house, and he, out of goodwill and professional commitment, invested $7,000 of his own money into the property for large disposal bins and extensive cleaning to prepare it for listing.

However, just days before the scheduled listing, the homeowner received a sheriff’s notice for eviction. At this point, the private lender decided to exercise its right to use its own preferred real estate agent to list the property, effectively sidelining Sarasin despite his significant investment and prior engagement. Sarasin reached out to the lender, highlighting his efforts and the bin still present in the driveway, only to be told, “They basically said that’s between you and the seller, so you’re going to have to go after them for that.” His plea to the lender – “I’ve already got the listing agreement signed, I’ve already had the property cleaned out, I’m local – why can’t we just work together to get it done?” – went unanswered.

This anecdote underscores the precarious position realtors can find themselves in. Despite signing listing agreements and investing time and money, their involvement can be abruptly terminated by the lender. It also highlights the lack of clarity and support for realtors caught in the middle of these high-stakes situations. The emotional toll on the homeowners is equally devastating, with Sarasin noting that many of his clients, even those who sold before falling too far behind, often find themselves with only enough funds for “a year or two” of rent. He grimly anticipates that many of these individuals “could end up on the streets,” emphasizing the severe social consequences of widespread mortgage defaults.

Preventative Measures: Proactivity and Expert Consultation

In a volatile market, proactive measures are not just advisable; they are essential for both homeowners and real estate professionals. Steven Sarasin urges realtors to adopt a more proactive stance with their clients, especially those holding variable-rate mortgages. “It’s like everything else – until it actually happens, they don’t think about it,” he observes. Realtors should regularly check in with clients, encouraging them to consult with a mortgage broker to understand their options and potential strategies *before* they fall into default. Early intervention can open doors to solutions like refinancing, payment restructuring, or even a timely sale to prevent a Power of Sale.

The Critical Need for Expert Advice: Brian Madigan’s Warnings

The complexities of Power of Sale transactions are such that many real estate agents and lawyers find themselves seeking specialized guidance. Brian Madigan, a seasoned realtor with Re/Max West Realty Rexdale in Toronto, is a frequently consulted expert. Having practiced law for 25 years before transitioning into real estate, Madigan has authored numerous articles on real estate topics, including the intricacies of Power of Sale.

Madigan notes that many realtors reaching out to him “have usually never experienced it before” and are often at a loss regarding the appropriate steps to take in a Power of Sale scenario. They ask fundamental questions such as, “How can you delay it? What arrangements can be made? What’s the best plan?” This highlights a significant knowledge gap within the industry regarding these specialized transactions.

A central tenet of Madigan’s advice revolves around the “schedule” that private lenders often attach to the standard Agreement of Purchase and Sale in Ontario. While schedules from the “Big Five” banks are generally standardized and understood, those from private lenders “can be very risky,” he cautions. He points out a critical oversight: many real estate agents “never read the schedule,” assuming it contains standard wording. This assumption is a perilous mistake, as private lender schedules frequently include “a number of very onerous provisions.”

Madigan, who acts as an expert witness in legal actions involving real estate agent negligence, frequently encounters realtors who inquire, “Is this something I have to worry about?” His emphatic answer is yes, absolutely. He stresses that these schedules “could contain a clause making the homeowner responsible for any liens on the house.” The dire consequence of overlooking such a detail could be a buyer purchasing a property for $1.2 million only to discover they are “stuck with $300,000 worth of liens because you didn’t know and you didn’t tell your client.” This scenario exposes realtors to significant liability for professional negligence.

Madigan’s counsel is clear: if realtors do not fully comprehend the provisions within a private lender’s schedule, they have a professional obligation to seek clarification. This could mean consulting their office’s broker of record, a trusted legal colleague, or, most importantly, advising their clients to obtain independent legal counsel. As he succinctly puts it, “I do appreciate it looks like legal gobbledygook, but read it.” The implications of not doing so can be financially devastating for both clients and the realtors themselves.

Conclusion: Adapting to a New Real Estate Reality

The growing prevalence of Power of Sale properties in Toronto and the wider GTA signals a notable shift in the region’s real estate dynamics. Driven by persistently high interest rates and economic pressures, more homeowners are unfortunately finding themselves in default, leading to an increase in lender-initiated sales. While these situations can present unique opportunities for savvy investors and buyers, they also come with significant risks and complexities.

For homeowners, the message is clear: proactive engagement with mortgage brokers and early action are paramount to exploring alternatives before a Power of Sale becomes inevitable. For real estate professionals, the current market demands heightened vigilance, a deeper understanding of Power of Sale procedures, and an unwavering commitment to client advocacy and due diligence. The insights from experts like Steven Sarasin and Brian Madigan underscore the critical importance of reading all documentation thoroughly, especially intricate schedules from private lenders, and seeking expert advice when uncertainty arises. Navigating this evolving landscape successfully will require adaptability, a commitment to education, and a keen awareness of the humanitarian aspects intertwined with these financial transactions.

Enjoying this article?

Get the latest REM articles in your inbox 3x week so you stay up to date on the latest in the Canadian real estate industry