Canadian Real Estate Market Navigates Uncertainty: Why Sellers Are Pulling Listings

The Canadian housing market is currently experiencing a notable shift, with a growing number of sellers opting to cancel their property listings rather than pushing for a sale in the prevailing conditions. This trend, highlighted by economist Daren King of National Bank Financial Markets, suggests a collective “wait and see” approach, driven largely by expectations of future interest rate adjustments.

In September, a significant 36 percent of listings in Ontario were cancelled, a sharp increase compared to the province’s average of 25 percent over the past few years. This pattern is not isolated to Ontario; nationwide, approximately 23.6 percent of all house listings are being pulled from the market, considerably higher than the typical average of 15.1 percent. This surge in cancellations points to a fundamental alignment between potential buyers and sellers: both are anticipating a decrease in interest rates in the coming months, influencing their strategic decisions.

As King explains, “I think they want to sell in a market that has some momentum. If you have the flexibility to push your transaction forward so that you can have a better selling price for more options when the market is more active, why not do it if you are able to?” This sentiment encapsulates the current strategic pause, where financial prudence dictates a temporary withdrawal from the market in anticipation of more favourable conditions.

Cancelled Listings Reach Unprecedented Levels, Signifying Market Hesitation

The data underpinning this trend is compiled by King from various sources, including the Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA), analyzing new listings, sales volumes, and active listings. While acknowledging that his figures for listing cancellations are “not an exact number,” he emphasizes their robustness and reliability. The implications are clear: a market grappling with uncertainty where the traditional flow of supply and demand is being interrupted by strategic withdrawals.

In an October House Price Index report for Teranet and National Bank, King elaborated on this phenomenon: “Despite a significant rise in the number of new listings on the resale market, inventory has been stalling over the past four months due to a large number of sellers deciding to cancel their listings each month.” This creates a perplexing scenario where, despite fresh properties entering the market, the overall active inventory struggles to expand, leading to a bottleneck in transactions.

The rise in cancelled listings is not merely a statistical anomaly; it’s a critical indicator of market sentiment and evolving dynamics. For homeowners, the decision to pull a listing often stems from a calculation that current market valuations, influenced by higher interest rates, do not meet their expectations. They are banking on an environment where lower borrowing costs will reignite buyer demand, leading to higher sale prices and more competitive offers.

Financial Flexibility: A Key Driver Behind Listing Withdrawals

While new listings across Canada saw a modest increase of 4.9 percent in September, sales volumes lagged significantly, rising by only 1.9 percent. Concurrently, the overall active listings inventory experienced a slight decrease, primarily attributed to the high rate of cancelled listings. This divergence highlights a market where supply is attempting to grow, but demand is not keeping pace, partially due to the strategic withdrawal of properties by sellers.

King speculates that some sellers who initially listed their homes this past fall might have anticipated a stronger market recovery as interest rates were projected to decline. When this rebound did not materialize as quickly or robustly as expected, they opted to cancel their listings, choosing to wait for a more definitive shift in market conditions. This reflects a reactive strategy, adapting to real-time market signals.

Intriguingly, King identifies a silver lining in this trend: the ability to cancel a listing often signals a healthy financial position on the part of the seller. “If you’re able to cancel your listing, it means you have the financial health to do it,” he notes, even amidst a slowing economy. This suggests that a significant portion of these sellers are not under duress to sell quickly. Instead, they possess the economic stability to defer their sale, whether due to stable employment, adequate savings, or a less urgent need to relocate.

“If you’re able to put your home for sale and cancel that listing and wait for later, that probably means that you didn’t lose your job,” King states. “It means that sellers have a quite good financial situation.” This perspective reframes the high cancellation rate not as a sign of widespread distress, but rather as an indication of resilience among Canadian homeowners, allowing them to ride out market fluctuations and await more opportune selling conditions.

Realtors Employ Strategic “Cancel-Relist” Tactics for Market Advantage

While increased, the phenomenon of cancelled listings is not entirely new. However, its current prevalence is “definitely higher than usual because (fewer houses) are selling,” observes Tom Storey, a seasoned Realtor and team leader at Royal LePage Signature in Toronto. This elevated rate underscores the competitive and often challenging environment sellers face today.

In dynamic markets like Toronto, where homes traditionally sell relatively quickly (often in less than 35 days), properties that linger on the market beyond this threshold can signal potential issues to buyers, whether real or perceived. To circumvent this, many astute sellers, in mutual agreement with their realtors, employ a strategic maneuver: they cancel the existing listing and then immediately relist the property, particularly if they are planning a price adjustment. This tactic is often preferred over simply changing the price on an active, aging listing.

Storey explains the rationale: “If you cancel the listing and relist it, it shows up as new, zero days on market, like a fresh listing at a new price. The history of the old one will still be there but it’s usually just a better way to show up at the front of any buyer that has automatic searches set up. Doing the cancel-relist typically works out a lot better than just doing a price change.” This strategy leverages buyer psychology and the mechanisms of online real estate portals, which often prioritize newer listings in search results and email alerts. A fresh listing, even if it’s a relist, generates renewed interest and positions the property as a “new opportunity” rather than a stagnant one.

However, the “cancel-relist” strategy is not a universal solution. Storey advises that it’s most effective for significant price reductions, indicating a genuine recalibration of seller expectations. For instance, a minor $10,000 price drop on a $900,000 property might not warrant a full cancel-relist, as it may not be perceived as a substantial enough change to justify the tactic. “Typically, cancelling-relisting makes sense if you’re doing a bigger drop in price,” he clarifies. Furthermore, this tactic is usually deployed sparingly. “Usually, we would do it only once to get at the price we think we should have,” Storey adds, suggesting that multiple cancel-relist cycles could eventually raise buyer suspicion.

Vancouver Market Shows Resilience Amidst National Trends

While the trend of listing cancellations is prevalent across Canada, some regional markets exhibit unique dynamics. Scott Moe, a Realtor with ReMax Treeland Realty in Metro Vancouver, notes that the majority of his clients have opted to maintain their house listings. However, he acknowledges “there is a lot of chatter” among sellers about whether to pull their properties off the market and wait until the following year to relist, mirroring the national sentiment of anticipation.

Moe’s advice to his clients highlights a crucial aspect of real estate transactions: “I tell people if you wait until next year, maybe the price for your house may be a little bit higher if interest rates keep going down, but what you’re going to buy is also going to be higher. When you buy and sell in the same market, you’re in the same position.” This pragmatic perspective underscores that while waiting for lower interest rates might increase selling prices, it also inflates buying costs within the same market, effectively neutralizing potential gains for those planning both a sale and a purchase. This insight encourages sellers to consider their holistic financial situation rather than focusing solely on the selling price in isolation.

Anticipating 2024: First-Time Buyers and Evolving Mortgage Regulations

Looking ahead to 2024, a significant cohort of market participants—first-time buyers—are poised to play a crucial role. Many are currently on the sidelines, patiently awaiting not only more favorable interest rates but also the implementation of updated mortgage regulations. A key change, set to come into effect in December, is the increase in amortization periods for insured mortgage loans from 25 to 30 years. This adjustment is expected to enhance affordability by reducing monthly mortgage payments, thereby making homeownership more accessible for eligible buyers.

King believes this impending regulatory change, coupled with the expectation of lower rates, is a primary reason for the current market pause. “I think that’s why there’s a lot of people on the sidelines. Sellers are waiting for buyers to come back to the market. That’s why we’re seeing those listings being cancelled.” This creates a temporary standoff, with each side awaiting the optimal moment to re-engage.

Mortgage advisors are already guiding first-time buyers through these strategic considerations. Some are recommending taking advantage of the new 30-year amortization period initially, and then, if financially feasible, switching back to a 25-year amortization upon renewal. This flexible approach allows buyers to benefit from lower initial payments while retaining the option to accelerate their mortgage repayment once their financial situation stabilizes or improves.

Furthermore, another significant change arriving on December 15th is the increase in the maximum home price for which buyers can obtain mortgage insurance when making a down payment of less than 20 percent. This cap will rise from $1-million to $1.5-million. Storey notes that this increase in the insured mortgage cap will enable a greater number of Toronto buyers, in particular, to qualify for home purchases, potentially exerting upward pressure on certain price points within the market.

Spring Market Anticipation: Buyers Eye Rate Relief

The collective gaze of the real estate market is firmly fixed on the spring of 2024, with widespread projections indicating a decrease in interest rates in the coming months. This anticipated rate relief is expected to significantly alter buyer behavior. King forecasts a return to historical norms, predicting that “it probably will go back to normal (with) about 25 percent of buyers taking the variable rate.” A shift towards variable-rate mortgages typically signals greater confidence in future rate declines and an appetite for more flexible financing options.

As interest rates began their modest descent in the fall, Moe observed an initial, cautious shift in buyer sentiment: “buyers are jumping off the fence a bit but not as much as they will in the spring when the rates come down even further.” This indicates a nascent awakening of demand, which is expected to gain considerable momentum as rates continue their downward trajectory.

Real estate agents across the country have already noticed a slight uptick in inquiries and calls over the past couple of weeks, suggesting that buyers are beginning to actively re-evaluate their positions. However, Moe issues a cautionary note to those still lingering on the sidelines: “Next spring might be the time buyers who were on the fence will probably say ‘I should have bought in the fall or winter.’” This sentiment highlights the potential for a surge in demand, which could lead to increased competition and potentially higher prices, making the current period a strategic window for decisive buyers.

The confluence of anticipated interest rate reductions, favorable mortgage regulation changes, and accumulating buyer demand sets the stage for a potentially robust Canadian real estate market in spring 2024. While sellers have paused, their strategic withdrawal has created pent-up supply that will likely be unleashed into a more active environment, offering a dynamic period for both buying and selling opportunities.

Enjoying this article?

Get the latest REM articles in your inbox 3x week so you stay up to date on the latest in the Canadian real estate industry.