KEY INSIGHTS
- The Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA) is exploring a potential shift of Realtor.ca from a non-profit to a for-profit, wholly-owned subsidiary model.
- A Special General Meeting (SGM) was convened on October 18 to seek member direction and support for Realtor.ca’s future.
- Key stakeholders, including the Alberta Real Estate Association (AREA), express significant reservations about “selling off a portion of Realtor.ca,” questioning the benefits to members.
- Technological advancement and scalability necessitate substantial capital, raising crucial questions about optimal capitalization strategies that align with member and consumer needs.
The landscape of Canadian real estate is on the brink of a significant transformation, as the future operational model of Realtor.ca, the nation’s premier property search portal, hangs in the balance. For several months, the Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA) has engaged in extensive consultations with various stakeholders regarding a potential transition from its long-standing non-profit status to a more commercially oriented, for-profit structure.
“We have been diligently consulting with realtors, as well as leaders from boards and associations across the country, through the Realtor.ca Task Force. Alongside external experts, we have undertaken initial due diligence to explore the viability of moving Realtor.ca into a separate, taxable, wholly-owned subsidiary of CREA,” stated Pierre Leduc, a spokesperson for CREA, underscoring the depth of consideration behind this strategic move.
CREA Seeks Direction on Realtor.ca’s For-Profit Future at SGM
A pivotal moment in this ongoing discussion occurred on October 18, when CREA convened a Special General Meeting (SGM). The primary objective of this gathering was to seek and collect directional endorsement from its members regarding the work accomplished to date and to outline the subsequent steps in this transformative journey. The outcome of this meeting is expected to significantly influence the trajectory of Realtor.ca.
“This represents an important and truly exciting phase for our organization, and it is imperative that we dedicate ample time to listen attentively and engage in thorough consultation,” Leduc emphasized. “The discussions held during the SGM will provide invaluable guidance to CREA’s Board of Directors as they deliberate on future work, which could potentially culminate in a formal vote on a detailed business plan at CREA’s Annual General Meeting (AGM) in April 2024. We are committed to providing further updates as more concrete information becomes available.”
However, the path towards this potential restructuring has been anything but smooth, marked by considerable debate and divergent perspectives among key real estate associations and boards across Canada.
Alberta Boards Challenge Proposed Realtor.ca Restructuring
The proposed shift has elicited strong reactions, particularly from Alberta’s real estate community. Christian Twomey, Chair of the Calgary Real Estate Board (CREB), detailed his disquieting experience as a member of CREA’s Realtor.ca Task Force, to which he was appointed on May 16 and from which he subsequently resigned on August 30. Twomey expressed that his initial apprehension regarding the process only intensified during his tenure on the task force.
“Immediately following my resignation, it became abundantly clear that significant challenges existed in achieving alignment between the Task Force and CREA concerning the optimal path forward for Realtor.ca. There appear to be systemic forces at play that are undermining sound governance,” Twomey asserted in a September 19 communication to CREB members.
He further highlighted procedural concerns: “Intriguingly, when CREA issued the notice for the October 18 SGM to all Boards and Associations across Canada on September 12, it had yet to present a formal motion for a vote. Leadership across the country was advised to attend this meeting in person for a ‘directional endorsement exercise on the future of Realtor.ca.’ For CREB, our steadfast goal remains ensuring Realtor.ca continues to serve as a reliable and indispensable source of business for our members.”
Brad Mitchell, CEO of the Alberta Real Estate Association (AREA), echoed these sentiments, articulating AREA’s profound concern about the absence of clear benefits associated with “selling off a portion of Realtor.ca.” Mitchell elaborated on the genesis of this discontent:
“Back in January, a considerable number of CREA members became aware of the board’s plan to essentially divest a portion of Realtor.ca. This prompted a collective response, with AREA, alongside nine other boards in Alberta, submitting a requisition for a Special General Meeting. The purpose was to propose bylaw changes that would prevent the CREA board from executing such a sale without a direct member vote,” Mitchell explained. “Consequently, this SGM serves as a crucial forum to discuss the fundamental future and operational framework of Realtor.ca, following recommendations brought forth by the task force.”
Mitchell conveyed that CREA’s initial proposition to sell a portion of Realtor.ca came as an unexpected surprise, with many feeling the plan lacked sufficient detail and thoughtful consideration.
“We unequivocally dislike the concept. CREA has, to date, failed to demonstrate any tangible advantage to introducing outside investors into the ownership structure. Moreover, it is a fundamental principle that minority shareholders, once introduced, possess significant rights. Currently, Realtor.ca is collectively owned by every realtor member in Canada and operates under a not-for-profit model. The moment external investors are brought in, their inherent objective will, naturally, be profit generation,” Mitchell emphasized, highlighting the potential conflict of interest.
“Revenue Should Benefit All Members in Canada” – A Call for Collective Advantage
Mitchell elaborated on his perspective regarding profit generation within the context of Realtor.ca: “There is ultimately only one legitimate avenue for profit: directly from the members themselves. They are the foundational architects and contributors to this system. While methods to generate revenue certainly exist, such revenue should be meticulously channeled for the collective benefit of all Canadians and, crucially, all members across Canada, rather than being diverted to a specific corporation or entity.”
He underscored AREA’s singular focus: safeguarding the interests of its members. “When the interests of our members are perceived to be under threat, we are prepared to act with utmost swiftness and decisiveness to protect those to whom we are accountable. Therefore, any proposition for the sale of Realtor.ca to any party outside the direct ownership of realtor members constitutes a non-starter for our provincial association, a stance shared by many boards within the province,” Mitchell firmly stated, reiterating the strong opposition.
The implications of such a sale extend beyond mere financial returns. It touches upon the very ethos of a member-driven organization, raising questions about control, transparency, and the potential erosion of a communal asset built over decades through collective investment and participation by Canadian real estate professionals. The concerns stem from a fear that a for-profit entity, driven by external shareholder demands, might prioritize commercial interests over the unique needs and benefits of its realtor members, potentially impacting service quality, innovation focus, or even the cost structure for members.
CREA’s Vision for Realtor.ca’s Evolution and Sustainability
The SGM agenda package contained a joint statement from Larry Cerqua, Chair of CREA, and Marina James, Chair of the Realtor.ca Task Force, outlining their perspective. They underscored Realtor.ca’s indispensable role in fostering the success and reputation of realtors across Canada, by consistently placing realtors at the core of consumer real estate journeys and delivering millions of high-quality leads to members annually.
“We deeply recognize the profound importance of this asset to the entire realtor association community. As responsible stewards of Realtor.ca, it is incumbent upon us to proactively prepare for and lead future technological advancements, all while ensuring the long-term sustainability and vitality of this truly unique and exceptionally important asset that consistently generates immense value for realtors and their clients,” they wrote, emphasizing the dual mandate of innovation and preservation.
The statement further explained that the task force has been diligently leading the initial due diligence process and actively assisting in charting a progressive path forward for the platform. This path envisions Realtor.ca transforming into a separate, taxable, and wholly-owned subsidiary of CREA, a structure designed to facilitate greater agility and investment in its technological evolution.
Realtor.ca: A Dominant Force in Property Search and Its Future Capital Needs
Lynette Keyowski, Managing Partner of REACH Canada, a prominent real estate technology scale-up program, offers an external perspective on Realtor.ca’s strategic position. REACH Canada is affiliated with the National Association of Realtors (NAR) in the United States, which serves as CREA’s American counterpart, and boasts a venture capital arm, Second Century Ventures, specifically designed to invest in real estate technology companies for the benefit of their realtor members.
Keyowski affirmed that abundant statistics and market data unequivocally demonstrate Realtor.ca’s status as a preeminent and highly significant force in property searches for Canadian consumers, solidifying its market leadership.
“From a strategic vantage point, Realtor.ca is unequivocally a viable and robust technology platform. It has consistently expanded its market share over time due to a confluence of factors, not least of which is the business model it employs. By virtue of its ownership through CREA, Realtor.ca has enjoyed what is essentially a monopoly on its most crucial asset: the comprehensive listing inventory,” Keyowski observed. “No other real estate portal in Canada can lay claim to such a monopoly on acquiring this foundational listing data. Any competing real estate portal must acquire this vital data through alternative means, whether through direct monetary transactions, financial agreements, or via affiliations, memberships, or partnerships of some nature with the entities that control the data.”
Keyowski further elucidated that CREA has leveraged this unique position to strategically cultivate and grow the Realtor.ca brand, primarily because it possesses the most extensive and complete database of available listings.
“From a purely forward-looking viability perspective, I strongly suspect the core discussion revolves around how to sustain the delivery of a product that the marketplace increasingly demands, given the existing ownership structure, and despite the inherent advantage of our monopoly on input data. I believe this is likely the crux of the ongoing conversation,” she suggested, highlighting the challenge of maintaining competitive edge while operating within historical frameworks.
Drawing on REACH’s extensive knowledge and operational experience, Keyowski underscored a universal truth in the technology sector: any technology function or platform aspiring to grow, scale, or significantly enhance its offerings necessitates substantial capital investment. This capital is crucial for everything from research and development into new features, cybersecurity upgrades, scaling infrastructure to handle increased user loads, to attracting and retaining top-tier talent in a competitive tech market.
“The fundamental question then becomes: How do you effectively capitalize that growth? How do you secure the necessary funding for that expansion? And critically, how do you ensure continuous capitalization to meet the ever-evolving and dynamically changing demands of a sophisticated consumer base?” Keyowski pondered. “Ultimately, I believe this boils down to two pivotal considerations: the efficiency and innovation of how you operate the business, and the strategic efficacy of how you capitalize the business.” The decision to move to a for-profit model is, therefore, an attempt to address this critical need for enhanced capitalization, but it must be carefully balanced with the foundational interests of its member-owners.
Enjoying this article?
Get the latest REM articles in your inbox 3x week so you stay up to date on the latest in the Canadian real estate industry